International commercial law refers to the set of rules and regulations governing business transactions across borders. In today's interconnected world, where global trade and commerce are growing at an unprecedented rate, international commercial law plays a crucial role in facilitating business transactions and ensuring that parties involved in such transactions are protected. However, conducting business on an international level is not without its challenges. There are various legal, cultural, linguistic, and technological barriers that businesses must navigate to ensure successful transactions.
Major Challenges for International Commercial Law
1. Differences in Legal Systems and Cultures
The first problem arising in international trade disputes and lawsuits is the nature and different types of legal systems in different countries. For example, common law relies heavily on judicial precedent, where decisions made in previous court cases serve as the basis for future decisions. This legal system is prevalent in countries that were colonised by the British, like the United States, Canada, and Australia. Civil law, on the other hand, is based on written laws and codes, which are created by legislative bodies in specific countries. This system is prevalent in countries like France, Germany, and Japan that follow the legal tradition of Roman law. Apart from these, religious laws can also govern a country's legal system. It is a legal system that is based on religious texts like the Quran or Sharia law in Islamic countries or the Torah or Mosaic law in Israel (Source: Wikipedia).
The legal systems of different countries can vary greatly, even within the same legal system category. For example, the legal system in the United States differs from that of the United Kingdom, despite both being common-law countries. The differences in legal systems and cultures pose several challenges for businesses operating on an international level. This is why international law is complex and requires experts with better qualifications and experience. For instance, contracts written under one legal system may not be enforceable under another legal system. Similarly, cultural differences can create misunderstandings and miscommunications between parties involved in business transactions. Legal systems also differ in their approaches to areas like intellectual property protection or dispute resolution. This impacts the outcome of international business transactions. Businesses must therefore be aware of these differences and take appropriate steps to mitigate the risks associated with them.
Related Blog - The Role of Contracts in International Commercial Law
2. Language Barriers
The world is full of diverse ethnicities, languages, and cultures. Every country has several languages spoken by its people. Even within a language, there will be considerable differences in the way it is spoken between a geographic area or culture. All these affect how the law is codified in a specific country. Different countries have their laws written in different languages (Source: Wikipedia). Language fosters bilateral trade. This also affects how the legal system works in a specific country. So these will result in language barriers for international law firms. Language barriers can take various forms, like difficulty understanding spoken language, reading and writing in a foreign language, or understanding cultural nuances in communication. These barriers can lead to errors in contracts, miscommunication during negotiations, and misunderstandings that can result in the loss of business opportunities.
Overcoming language barriers is critical to success in international business. Effective communication is key to building relationships, establishing trust, and ensuring successful outcomes in business transactions. Hiring staff who are fluent in the language of the country where business is being conducted can help bridge the language gap (Source: Empirical Economics). Professional translation services can also be used to accurately translate documents, contracts, and communications. Moreover, learning the language of the country can help build trust with local partners and facilitate better communication. It also gives better relationship-building and networking opportunities. Moreover, learning a new language can be fun and fulfilling for international law professionals. Apart from these, using simple language, avoiding idioms or complex sentence structures, and understanding cultural differences in communication help avoid misunderstandings.
Related Blog - Key Topics in International Commercial Law: What Every LLM Aspirant Should Know
3. Intellectual Property Protection
Intellectual property refers to creations of the mind like inventions, literary and artistic works, designs, symbols, and names used in commerce. Intellectual property protection provides exclusive rights to the creators of these intangible assets, allowing them to control their use and distribution. This protection is critical for encouraging innovation and creativity, as it provides incentives for individuals and companies to invest time and resources in developing new products, services, and technologies without worrying about piracy, theft, or unauthorised use.
Patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets are also intellectual properties concerning businesses. Patents protect inventions and grant the owner exclusive rights to make, use, and sell the invention for a specified period. Trademarks protect brand names, logos, and symbols used in commerce and prevent others from using similar marks that could confuse consumers. Copyrights protect original works of authorship like books, music, and movies and give the creator the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, and display their work. Trade secrets are confidential business information like formulas, processes, and customer lists that give a company a competitive advantage.
Protecting all these entities requires international cooperation and legal systems that can manage them between countries (Source: UpCounsel). In international business, intellectual property protection can be challenging due to differences in laws, regulations, and enforcement across countries. Some countries may have weaker or non-existent intellectual property laws, making it easier for competitors to copy and exploit intellectual property without consequences. This can harm the original creators and stifle innovation. This is a major challenge for international trade law practitioners to overcome.
Several strategies are used to protect intellectual property in international business. First and foremost, companies should register their intellectual property through patents and trademarks in each country where they operate. This provides legal protection and can help deter infringement in the future. They should also research the intellectual property laws and regulations in each country in which they operate and assess the risk of infringement. This helps companies develop a plan for protecting their intellectual property. Further, they can use contracts to protect their intellectual property, such as non-disclosure agreements and licensing agreements. These contracts prevent competitors and employees from misusing or stealing intellectual property. Finally, companies should monitor the use of their intellectual property and take action to enforce their rights if they suspect infringement. This includes sending cease-and-desist letters, filing lawsuits, or working with local law enforcement to seize counterfeit goods.
Related Blog - Intellectual Property Protection in the Global Marketplace
4. Compliance with Local Laws and Regulations
Compliance with local laws and regulations is critical for businesses operating in foreign countries. Local laws and regulations can vary widely, and failure to comply with them can result in complex legal issues, hefty financial penalties, reputational damage, and the loss of business opportunities. It is harder for international law practitioners to fight a case in international courts if the company is found not to be following the law. Hence, the importance of compliance with local laws and regulations cannot be overstated. It helps businesses build trust with local stakeholders, including customers, suppliers, and government officials. Compliance also ensures that businesses operate within the framework of the law, promoting a level playing field and preventing unfair competition.
However, compliance with local laws and regulations can also pose significant challenges. For instance, regulations may be complex and difficult to understand, or they may be enforced inconsistently. Local cultural norms and practices may also differ from those of the business's home country, leading to misunderstandings and unintended violations. Hence, it is a challenge for international trade law practitioners to avoid these pitfalls. To ensure compliance with local laws and regulations, businesses and legal professionals can follow several strategies.
Before entering a foreign market, businesses and international trade law practitioners should conduct thorough due diligence to understand local laws and regulations. This includes researching laws and regulations related to their industry, as well as cultural norms and practices. Businesses should seek the advice of local legal counsel along with international legal systems to help navigate complex laws and regulations. Legal counsel can also guide cultural norms and practices that may be relevant to compliance.
International businesses should develop internal policies and procedures that reflect local laws and regulations. Further, you should provide training and education to employees so that they are well-versed in local laws and regulations and cultural norms and practices. This ensures that employees understand their responsibilities and prevents unintentional violations. Finally, international businesses should conduct regular audits to ensure that they comply with local laws and regulations. Audits can help identify areas of non-compliance and provide opportunities for corrective action.
Related Blog - Key Topics in International Commercial Law: What Every LLM Aspirant Should Know
5. Cybersecurity Challenges for International Law
Cybersecurity is crucial for the protection of computer systems, networks, and sensitive information from unauthorised access, theft, and damage. In the digital age, no organisation is free from the threat of cyberattacks. In international business, cybersecurity is critical for protecting sensitive data and intellectual property from cyber threats like hacking, phishing, and ransomware attacks. Cyber threats are constantly evolving with time. Hence, businesses are at risk of losing valuable data, reputation, and financial assets if they fail to adequately protect themselves. Cybersecurity is also essential for compliance with laws and regulations related to data privacy and security in an international setting (Source: Brookings).
Different countries have different laws and regulations related to cybersecurity, and these regulations can be complex and difficult to navigate. Moreover, the digital transformation and adaptation of technology are not the same in every country. While some areas and countries have affordable and stable internet, many countries are still experimenting with the infrastructure needed to bring internet. Language and cultural barriers can also make it challenging to communicate cybersecurity risks and best practices effectively. The lack of cyber security awareness is also rampant around the globe. Hence, it is a major challenge for international law professionals to deal with cybersecurity-related legal issues.
As a means of fighting cyber attacks, businesses should conduct regular risk assessments to identify potential vulnerabilities and areas of exposure to cyber threats. Thus, they can develop targeted cybersecurity strategies and allocate resources effectively. Implementing robust cybersecurity protocols like firewalls, antivirus software, and encryption helps prevent unauthorised access and data theft. Further, employees are often the weakest link in cybersecurity, so businesses should provide regular training and education on best practices for cybersecurity. This can include identifying phishing emails, using strong passwords, and avoiding risky online behaviour. This is also where legal complications become harder for companies and international trade law professionals to deal with.
For example, if an unsuspecting employee uses a malicious USB drive on their desktop and risks a data breach, they will be at the mercy of local cybersecurity laws. The competence of the legal system, corruption, incompetence, and political pressure can all complicate the issue further. Avoiding this requires better academic qualifications, in-depth knowledge of different legal systems in different countries, and skills.
Finally, building partnerships with cybersecurity experts, law enforcement agencies, and other businesses to share information and resources helps businesses stay ahead of emerging threats and develop effective responses to cyber attacks. Moreover, conducting regular audits of their cybersecurity systems and protocols to identify potential vulnerabilities and areas for improvement helps them stay up-to-date with evolving threats and technologies. All these strategies will strengthen organisations in the international legal system domain.
Related Blog - Effect of Geopolitical Crises on Businesses
Conclusion
With the ongoing globalisation and the digital opportunities provided by the internet, it is now possible for even small and medium-sized businesses to scale globally. Multinational companies and cross-country trade have become the norm recently. For businesses operating in border regions, it is now easier than ever to trade across the border, both online and offline. However, the legal complexities involved in international trade cannot be neglected. This is why, in recent times, there has been a growing demand for international trade law services.
Legal professionals can use this opportunity to advance their careers and get more earning opportunities. However, some challenges remain in the domain. Differences in legal systems and cultures are a major barrier to international trade, as they make it harder to cope with disputes. Language barriers can also affect the operational structure of businesses. Moreover, protecting intellectual property can be challenging, as several countries do not have strict legal measures against piracy and theft of intellectual property. Compliance with local laws and regulations can also hinder companies from taking advantage of initial opportunities. Finally, cybersecurity is a major challenge for businesses, even in international law-related issues.
If you are a lawyer with management experience, SNATIKA offers you the opportunity to earn a European Master's degree! SNATIKA has a prestigious LLM program and an MBA program in international trade law. These programs are designed exclusively for senior professionals, keeping in mind their learning challenges, expectations, and academic needs. Check out the programs and their benefits on the SNATIKA website. Visit SNATIKA now.
Related Blog - Top Reasons to Pursue an LLM in International Commercial Law
Citations
Fidrmuc, J., Fidrmuc, J. Foreign languages and trade: evidence from a natural experiment. Empir Econ 50, 31–49 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00181-015-0999-7